StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Thought Paper on Dahl Book - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Dahl, R. A. (2001) How Democratic is the American Constitution? New Haven: Yale University Press. Dahl’s book is a thoughtful reflection on the form and nature of the American Constitution, whether or not it has served its country well, and whether any further amendments to it are necessary or likely given the present climate and thinking on constitutional issues…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.7% of users find it useful
Thought Paper on Dahl Book
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Thought Paper on Dahl Book"

Download file to see previous pages

Two main themes stand out from Dahl’s analysis – his look at the ‘profound ignorance’ (p.7) of the Framers of America’s future, and thus the need to periodically amend it, and the fact that it has not been adopted by other democratic countries. Dahl begins with the basics, asking why we should uphold the Constitution, and stating that his aim ‘is not to propose changes in the American Constitution but to suggest changes in the way we think about our constitution’ (p.1). His book starts on the right note by immediately admitting the imperfection of American constitutional arrangements – at the Constitutional Convention held in Philadelphia, Rhode Island sent no delegates, while those from New Hampshire arrived weeks late.

Not only was this an irregular start, but Dahl rightly asks why Americans should still feel bound to a document signed by only 39 men, some of whom owned slaves. When Dahl notes that there had never since been a referendum on it, one wonders if perhaps there should have been. Dahl is not unduly harsh to the Framers of the Constitution, recognizing that they were a product of their times, and that ‘Judged from later, more democratic perspectives’, the document has many shortcomings (p. 15).

However, given this fact, Dahl is right that Americans should look upon it as the work of mortal men, and a practical and changing document, rather than a sacred text to be preserved. For example, with slavery, it was clear that the delegates from the southern states would never accept anything which didn’t allow slavery to continue, and so it was allowed for the sake of a strong federal government. Again, with the unequal representation in the Senate – a point which arises repeatedly in Dahl’s work as a weak point of the Constitution – the smaller states would never have accepted anything less than equal representation with the larger states.

There is a tendency to assume that, because the Constitution retains the support of most Americans, and because of the idealistic portrayal of its origins, its status as a basically good document need not be questioned. What is most striking about Dahl’s work is his comparison of the American Constitution with that of other countries with a strong democratic tradition, out of which comes one major point – if the American Constitution was such a wonderful document, surely it would have been adapted by other countries seeking a democratic model.

As Dahl himself writes, ‘Many Americans appear to believe that our constitution has been a model for the rest of the democratic world’, but of the 22 other democracies analyzed, America is unique (p.41). Some countries share some aspects of the US constitution, such as its federalism, or its strong judicial review mechanisms, but none has several key features in common. Especially interesting in this regard is the American presidential system, which allows for a uniquely powerful head of state, who, since the office is now filled by popular election, is like ‘a monarch and prime minister rolled into one’ (p.72). We must agree with the author that such a powerful position does not really seem appropriate in a modern democracy.

However, this is not the worst of the defects of the constitution as it now stands. More

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Thought Paper on Dahl Book Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1408216-thought-paper-on-dahl-book
(Thought Paper on Dahl Book Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words)
https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1408216-thought-paper-on-dahl-book.
“Thought Paper on Dahl Book Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1408216-thought-paper-on-dahl-book.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Thought Paper on Dahl Book

How the Liberal Democracies in the Western States Such the US, U.K and France Changed

The paper 'How the Liberal Democracies in the Western States Such the US, U.... and France Changed" states that depoliticizing the military is a crucial step towards successful democratization.... This eliminates events such as military coups, which are rampant in some African nations....
11 Pages (2750 words) Research Paper

Gender Difference in Social Anxiety using Social Phobia Inventory

Social phobia, also known as social anxiety disorder is described in the DSM-IV-TR as a “marked and persistent fear of one or more social and performance situations in which embarrassment may occur” (American Psychiatric Association [DSM-IV-TR], 2000).... According to current… However there is an absence of a significant piece of information to note which is not in the clinical samples among patients with social phobia (DSM-IV-TR, 2000)....
18 Pages (4500 words) Term Paper

:Annotated Bibliograghy

Various concepts of dietary requirement for health living are provided in this book.... As a result, this book is useful in… Anderson's book will provide a deeper insight into the three aspects of healthy living hence providing research foundation. Birchall develops a diet after his name.... In this diet, the author attempts to provide a diet free According to this book, it is better for individuals to engage in dietary practices without pills and frills....
4 Pages (1000 words) Research Paper

The New Yorker Digitalized

Besides, record of numbers by a copy-book, including rather long ("for the-seven thousand" instead of "47000") is accepted.... Among The New Yorker's writers there were Vladimir Nabokov, Roland dahl, Haruki Murakami, J.... The New Yorker is an American weekly magazine publishing reportages, commentary, criticism, essays, fiction, comics, and poetry produced by Condé Nast....
7 Pages (1750 words) Research Paper

Book Review of How Democratic Is the American Constitution by Robert A. Dahl second edition

It has also outlined the various systems of… The paper aims at reviewing a book written by Robert A.... The book acts as a reminder.... dahl, touching on the subject matter of democracy and the American constitution.       The American Constitution often acts as a reference to the American democracy's foundation.... dahl considers the Constitution in the light of issues with consideration of the historical circumstances, which surrounded its creation....
4 Pages (1000 words) Book Report/Review

Theories of Business Power

The present paper "Theories of Business Power" explores the ideas of business power.... As the author puts it, business power is defined as the driving force for an act by an industry, a company or sector with its primary source being a grant of authority from the society....
12 Pages (3000 words) Research Paper

Performing Popular Music

The paper "Performing Popular Music" studies emotion and physiology in relation to expression using voice and body language during a musical performance, reflects the author's emotional and physical state in singing while applying some of the theories of stage art to his on-stage performance.... The   Objectives of this Major Project are as follows: To produce and perform a 45 minutes recital, on June 18th, 2007,  at Coombeburst Studio, Kingston University, and the final research paper that contains the analysis of the important relationship between emotion and physiology while performing popular music....
14 Pages (3500 words) Research Paper

Scientific Evaluation of the American Public Administration

The paper presents Weber's model of bureaucracy and merit system according to which administrators are appointed due to expertise and qualifications, to ensure efficient achievement of collective aims.... This essay analyzes the scientific approach and its impact on the US Public administration....
11 Pages (2750 words) Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us