StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Workplace Law - Case Study Example

Cite this document
Summary
The case states that no formal contract or agreement was signed between the employee, Jane Jones and the employer - T Total Mechanic Management Services Pty Ltd…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.9% of users find it useful
Workplace Law Case Study
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Workplace Law"

?Workplace Law- Case Study The case s that no formal contract or agreement was signed between the employee, Jane Jones and the employer - T Total Mechanic Management Services Pty Ltd. However, according to Common Law, when any firm agrees to hire or employ an individual a contract of employment is said to have been made, regardless of whether it was formally signed or not. Hence all the laws and regulations related to awards, state or federal industrial laws are applicable and can be enforced, in case of such contracts (CCH Australia, 2010). For the purpose of this case study, the contractual true nature of contractual relationship of Jane Jones and TMMS will be studied from the perspective of Common Law, and the various legal issues pertaining to the case will be discussed, by application of principles and facts of the said case. The various legal issues, as pertains to the Common Law, related to this case are listed below: 1. Breach of implied duty of mutual trust and confidence In accordance with the proceedings and decision arrived at by the Supreme Court of Australia, in the McDonald v State of South Australia, it was established that the elements such as mutual trust and confidence are an integral and inevitable part of employment contracts. The judiciary in Australia uses the implied term of trust and confidence in order to create an obligation on the part of the employers so as to instill an interest of fairness. It is described as "an implied obligation of good faith". It was observed in the case of Concut Pty Ltd v Worrel, that "the ordinary relationship of an employer and employee at common law is one importing implied duties of loyalty, honesty, confidentiality and mutual trust" (Aras, Crowther, 2010, pp. 517; Brodie, 2010, pp. 166). In this case, TMMS summoned Jane and made sudden changes in the contract, which included terms and conditions which were unfair to her, and did not seek to protect her interests at work. One of the implied rules of common law states that the employees be treated in a fair manner, while the terms and conditions and the abrupt changes made, were both unfair and unjust for Jane. The employer in this case had an implied obligation to treat their employees fairly and be honest and truthful to them. Furthermore, the employer is also required to practice and apply the elements of confidentiality and strive to maintain mutual trust. But in this case, TMMS decided to restructure its organization and did not take their employees into confidence prior to making any changes to their employment terms, and instead added clauses which were unjust and unfair to them. 2. Refusing to sign, negotiate, extend or vary an AWA Under Common Law, neither the employer nor the employee has the right to unilaterally alter the terms and conditions of an employment contract. Any such alteration must be done through mutual discussion and agreement, else it would be deemed illegal. The employer must obtain a valid consent of the employee prior to changing any of the terms of the employment contract and cannot do so just by serving a notice. Furthermore, it has also been stated under the Common Law, that the courts and tribunals will consider an agreement received by the employer, as illegal if the consequence of non-compliance or non-acceptance to sign the renewed contract is dismissal with immediate effect. In such a situation, the courts will deem such changes to the contract / agreement as unfair and adverse to the interest of the employees (Lewis & Sargeant, 2004, pp. 136). In this case, the employer TMMS, not only changed the terms of contract unilaterally, but also failed to discuss or negotiate the newly added terms with the employee. Furthermore, when specifically asked for more time to consider the said changes, TMMS openly stated that it is a “take it or leave it” situation, and implied that refusing to accept the said changes, would automatically result in termination of the contract. Such harsh terms and conditions not only broke the implied rule of mutual trust and confidence between the employer and employee, but also violated the principle of common law which suggests that any changes to an existing agreement must be made through mutual agreement and / or discussion. Since the employee in this case was left with no option was cornered by the employer, she had to sign the contract, under conditions which were both unfair as well as damaging for her future security. 3. Unlawful termination – termination of an employee without prior notice Such a termination is said to have occurred when an employee is dismissed by an employer without prior notice. Common Law allows / provides for such a dismissal and it is considered perfectly legal (i.e. within the purview of common law), except in the following cases/situations: when the employee is held guilty of misconduct; the employee fails to act in a reasonable manner or follow the commands / instructions applicable to them within the workplace; fails to be faithful to the service; causes damage to the money or property of the employer; discloses employment / trade secrets to competitors i.e. fails to maintain confidentiality of the trade (Fleming, 2004, pp. 146; Caisley, 2008, pp. 70-71). However, in this case the employee Jane Jones was immediately terminated / dismissed from work, as soon as the employers found out about her being incapacitated permanently on account of an accident that took place while on job. The manner and cause of termination are both illegal under Common Law since the employee had not violated any of the terms of her contract. The common law requires the employer to provide a formal notice to the employee prior to terminating their contract or dismissing them from employment. Although, the common law allows for immediate / summary dismissal it does not apply in this case as Jane did not violate any of the terms which attract such a dismissal. Conclusion: The relationship between an employer and employee inherently implies an inequality where the balance of power is tilted in favour of the employers. Hence the elements such as mutual trust and confidence, terms and conditions for unfair dismissal etc are incorporated and enforced by way of common law which applies to all forms of employment regardless of whether the contract was express or implied, and seeks to protect and safeguard the interests of employees as well as the employers. References: Aras, G., Crowther, D., (2010). A handbook of corporate governance and social responsibility, Gower Publishing, pp. 517-518 Brodie, D., (2010). Enterprise liability and the common law. Cambridge University Press, pp. 166-170 Caisley, K. T., (2008). Termination of employment: A best practice guide, CCH New Zealand Limited, pp. 71-73 CCH Australia (2010). Australian master fair work guide, CCH Australia Limited Publication, pp. 466 Fleming, L., (2004). Excel HSC Business studies, Pascal Press, pp. 146 Lewis, D., Sargeant, M., (2004). Essentials of employment law, CIPD Publishing, pp. 136 Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Workplace Law Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words”, n.d.)
Workplace Law Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1432905-workplace-law-case-study
(Workplace Law Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words)
Workplace Law Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words. https://studentshare.org/law/1432905-workplace-law-case-study.
“Workplace Law Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1432905-workplace-law-case-study.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Workplace Law Case Study

Manmade Hazards and Disasters

Department of Labor, Bureau of Labor Statistics, Census of Fatal Occupational Injuries Charts (1992-2008) explains workplace violence as intricate and risky work-related hazards that many employees go through every new day.... Department of Justice, Bureau of Justice Statistics (1993), the advancement of workplace violence has developed the understanding of the connection with the persons responsible for the violence to the victims and has led to the creation of theoretical structures of connecting the causes and prevention measures of workplace violence (p56)....
6 Pages (1500 words) Case Study

Violence In The Workplace And Responsibility For It

Violence in the workplace is an alarming global problem.... The paper "Violence In The workplace And Responsibility For It" discusses the workplace violence epidemic and what to do about it.... Based on the survey made by the Bureau o Women and Young Workers ( BWYW), nineteen out of fifty bank employees in the Philippines said that they have experienced sexual harassment at the workplace.... omicide is also one of the tops of workplace violence list among Filipino workers....
7 Pages (1750 words) Case Study

Case Study from Employment Law

In the recent Case Study from Employment law Introduction The history of the employment laws in the United Kingdom can be traced way back to the early 18th century (Dawson, 1898, p.... mployment law Case StudyIn the case study, there are very serious violations of the law that are evident.... However, in some cases, work place harassment and victimization are not prohibited by the law no matter how abusive they can be.... It is against the law to discriminate a person for holding or not holding a religious belief....
2 Pages (500 words) Case Study

Sample Case: Diversity in Law. Enforcement: The Report Egidio A. Diodati Assumption CoJlege

It would be better if the organization changes its internal CASE STUDY Diversity in law Enforcement: The Report Egidio A.... The law should be strictly followed without leaving any chances.... Even if a workplace should be a conducive place for all the employees, things seem to be different in this organization.... Even if a workplace should be a conducive place for all the employees, things seem to be different in this organization....
2 Pages (500 words) Case Study

The Women Position at the Workplace

n the USA, Great Britain and many other developed countries the rights of women for equal conditions with men are affirmed in the law, and the attempt to violate these rights as a rule results in multimillion claims to the violator.... The given paper will provide the overview of the case, women's position at the workplace and offer possible solutions.... The few less than 2000 employees of the Wallmart Company from 48 states of the USA submitted multimillion claims about gender discrimination at the workplace: managers of supermarkets raised salaries and offered career advancement only to men....
5 Pages (1250 words) Case Study

The Concerns of the Empire Hotel at the Fortitude Valley

(1999, 39), a workplace health and safety audit identifies a workplace's health and safety performance in relation to its compliance with the law and regulations.... hellip; To ensure a company is allied with the legislation in terms of its health and safety, it is vital for a company to operate along with the workplace health and safety regulations.... In the context of analyzing the health and safety aspects, a workplace inspection also called job performance sampling, is done to identify the work procedures and the policies....
10 Pages (2500 words) Case Study

Health, Safety, and Environment: Harvest Time Bakery Tragedy

… The paper "Health, Safety, and Environment: Harvest Time Bakery Tragedy" is a good example of a case study on the law.... The paper "Health, Safety, and Environment: Harvest Time Bakery Tragedy" is a good example of a case study on the law.... This report investigates the legal impact of workplace accidents through the use of a case study.... This report investigates the legal impact of workplace accidents through the use of a case study....
8 Pages (2000 words) Case Study

The Concept of Equality and Diversity in the Workplace

In the UK and elsewhere in the world, equality and diversity in the workplace are used in reference to the need to foster and promote differences and non-discriminate human resources (law ltd 2011).... According to law Ltd (2011), diversity management involves the active encouragement of employees from diverse backgrounds to join the workforce.... diversity management and equal opportunities) complement each other in that equal opportunities to diverse groups of employees create a diverse workforce, which necessitates the need for diversity management (law Ltd 2011)....
6 Pages (1500 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us