StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Whale Rider. Movie and the book, which one is better - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Whale Rider. Movie and book, which one is better?
Many books have been made into movies, and they are often not at all faithful to the original, other than the name, and usually the names of the characters…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.6% of users find it useful
Whale Rider. Movie and the book, which one is better
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Whale Rider. Movie and the book, which one is better"

Whale Rider Many books have been made into movies, and they are often not at all faithful to the original, other than the and usually the s of the characters. It is easy to name all the recent failings- The Da Vinci Code, Sahara, and many more. Rarely does it go the other way, although few would argue that the book Jurassic Park is as good as the movie! Whale Rider is yet another book that has been taken by the screen industry, and morphed into a movie. Yet, there is little that can be complained about.

While the book itself is powerful, the changes made to create a movie from the story bring it to life, making it a story of power and a happily ever after for those who watch it. Everything comes out right, and everyone learns a powerful lesson. While many would argue that all movies should stay loyal to the text they are inspired by, many are just that, only inspired. The story stays enough the same that people recognize the link, but the story being told is different. In those cases, it does not seem logical or reasonable for the movie to strictly follow the book.

In many cases (such as Jurassic Park) it does not make sense, as the book has scenes and moments that either cannot be portrayed cinematically, or that draw from the primary plot, and damage the story. Movies are limited in both time, and in their ability to accurately portray everything that a book can get across, and the same is true in reverse. Where a movie portrays emotion, a book might share each character's innermost thoughts, which is hard to do on a large screen. So it becomes necessary to change the story enough that it will be successful cinematically, but also still follow the story.

The Whale Rider is an excellent example. To make the book more cinematic, it was necessary to change the perspective from the uncle to the girl. In doing this, the two primary characters are easier to find and follow in the film. The story maintains both its' integrity, and its strength, but is also more pleasing to the audience. By placing the story in the view of a child, the movie becomes more children friendly, and since the story seems aimed at children, this was a logical move. So should movies stay loyal to their cinematic precursor Yes and no.

Yes, in that they need to maintain the integrity of the story that they have chosen to use, an no, because while they draw inspiration from the piece, it is still another form of art, that has its own strengths and weaknesses. While some (those that are meant to be a film portrayal of the story) should remain as loyal as possible, others that are only inspired by the story should be allowed creative freedom to stray from the original story line. Movies and books on the same topic will always incite controversy.

However, at least for the Whale Rider, both have value and strength which they share with their audience, and should continued to be enjoyed, whether or not the movie follows exactly the book.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Whale Rider. Movie and the book, which one is better Essay”, n.d.)
Whale Rider. Movie and the book, which one is better Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1510047-whale-rider
(Whale Rider. Movie and the Book, Which One Is Better Essay)
Whale Rider. Movie and the Book, Which One Is Better Essay. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1510047-whale-rider.
“Whale Rider. Movie and the Book, Which One Is Better Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1510047-whale-rider.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Whale Rider. Movie and the book, which one is better

Analysis of Film The Maltese Falcon

In the words of Huston, "the previous screenwriters had kept trying to 'lick the book,' instead of filming the book.... In this regard, Bremer quotes Bluestone's Novels Into Films, (According to Bluestone, literature and film are autonomous forms of artistic expression, one communicating with written words, the other with visual images.... This transposition from one medium to another hardly justifies either medium.... 3In his article, From Word to Word-Image: Film Translation of a "Sketchy" Chinese Short Story: Spring Silkworm, Literature Film Quarterly, 2005 Wang, Yiman, mentions, "The moralistic discourse to which Stam refers prioritizes the question of fidelity involved in translating one medium (the verbal fiction) into another (the visual film)....
8 Pages (2000 words) Movie Review

Professional Sports in American History

The wider the intentended audience for a work art, the less likely one is to see nuance and subtlety.... the book and subsequent film Eight Men Out both portray one of the lowest points in professional sports in American history.... Both the book and the movie present this story in terms of vast panorama of characters from the baseball world, the newspaper world and the underworld.... As a result, neither the book nor the movie contain what is traditionally considered to be a protagonist, the type of character that someone gets emotionally involved with and roots for....
5 Pages (1250 words) Movie Review

West of Jesus: Surfing, Science and the Origins of Belief by Steven Kotler

The overall argument of Steven Kotler's engaging book is the fact that when one is at one's lowest there is an opportunity for hope and a return to a perhaps better life.... … The overall argument of Steven Kotler's engaging book is the fact that when one is at one's lowest there is an opportunity for hope and a return to a perhaps better life than the person had before.... The literary theme that will be considered in detail here is the quest that Kotler is essentially going on throughout the book....
5 Pages (1250 words) Book Report/Review

German and British Films Analyses

The first one tells about the lives of those in Germany five years before the collapsing of the Wall.... he director did offer some skill in the forms of camera angles, which helped to portray the varying twists of this story.... The director used a lot of extreme close-ups and close-ups, which allowed the audience to feel more connected with the characters of the story.... Since the movie was an adaptation from a book, Boyle had to try hard to make the film his own; he played around with the questions on the game show and had them coincide with the life of the protagonist....
6 Pages (1500 words) Movie Review

US History Since 1887

The Joads are happy to have Tom back and they tell him about their plans to go to California, the land where they think they could find work and start living in a better condition.... Although she was the one who did not want to go to California as her intuitions were telling her that something is wrong in going there, but her immense support for the family is depicted when she is shown to add a drug to rigid Pas coffee to get him into the truck.... The 1939 Hollywood movie Grapes of Wrath directed by John Ford is based on the novel written by John Steinback and won the National Book Award and the Pulitzer Prize for fiction, it led its author to win Nobel Prize in 1962. The movie is about the struggle of a family, The… s, and other people who belonged to Oklahoma, a state worst hit by The Great Depression, an economic downfall which hit North America in 1929,resulting in crashing of stock market and strained banks and other financial institutions which failed by 1933....
5 Pages (1250 words) Movie Review

Bicycle Thieves by Vittorio de Sica

It adds more meaning to the movie since the story deals with the time and space (post-War industrial Italy) in which it is screened.... The scene in which the workman and the son seek shelter from the rain and are being surrounded by the insensible young seminarians chattering, the scene inside the church, the scene in which the boy runs in front of a vehicle and has to stop as his father moves ahead unawares – all these are sufficient to prove that Bicycle Thieves is pure cinema, incorporating the real events into the fictional reality of it....
6 Pages (1500 words) Movie Review

Not Without My Daughter Critique

The movie is based on the true story of Betty Mahmoody published as a book in 1986.... ilmott, having all the trappings of the tearjerker movie with colonial overtones.... nbsp;Released in 1990, the movie is full of clichés about the East, especially the Middle East.... hellip; Depicting the movie as a struggle between the good and the evil, where good is the white race, and evil, the brown, the movie was timed to be released on the eve of the first Gulf War....
6 Pages (1500 words) Movie Review

The Riverkeepers by Cronin and Kennedy

The review "The Riverkeepers by Cronin and Kennedy" asserts the book managed to arouse the interest of people on environmental issues.... If the authors included maps of the River Hudson's environmental issue this would be important for people not familiar with the locations mentioned in the book.... The fundamental theme of the book is to provoke the readers to view environmental protection as personal responsibility and demand responsible authorities to protect the environment as a fundamental and inalienable human right....
6 Pages (1500 words) Book Report/Review
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us