StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Should juveniles be waivered to adult court - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The most common form, judicial wavers, are used by a judge after a hearing to determine if a youth is a threat to his or her environment…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.3% of users find it useful
Should juveniles be waivered to adult court
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Should juveniles be waivered to adult court"

The Effects of Not Having Enough Detail about Judges or Offenders: A Literature Review of “The end of the line: An empirical study of judicial waiver.” With recent significant increases in youth violence, criminals courts have begun to apply several techniques to handle juvenile offenders. The most common form, judicial wavers, are used by a judge after a hearing to determine if a youth is a threat to his or her environment and if the offender would do well with treatment. Little information exists, however, about the statistics surrounding waivers, which makes “The End of the Line” a valuable analysis.

Within the study, Podkopacz and Feld analyzed 330 transfer motions in Hennepin Minnesota filed between 1986 and 1992 and recorded various information about waivers including their involvement in criminal court processing, sentencing, and recidivism of youth offenders. Podkopacz and Feld make several errors while attempting to draw a relationship between their localized studies and the role of waivers in court systems throughout the country. The study takes particular effort in ensuring that the population sample drawn from Hennepin’s records is reflective of the waiver trends Minnesota as well the United States.

While the study succeeds in showing that its offender population generally reflects trends throughout the United States, the authors do not show that the judges sampled in the study are representative of the judges throughout Minnesota and the United States. If the authors had attempted to craft a more detailed profile of the judges, who made the subjective decision to issue the wavers, and drew a comparison to judges throughout the country, it would follow the judges elsewhere would make similar subjective decisions.

The authors take a conservative stance on recidivism by choosing to allow actual adjudications or convictions to stand as indicators of recidivism rather than rearrests. The authors claim that recidivism rates of juveniles indicate that court systems are not achieving their goal. When in fact, consideration of the types of crimes committed by repeat offenders may show that these additional offenses are significantly less in magnitude than the original crimes. Thus, the legal system may be “working” towards deterring juvenile offenders from additional offenses but not enough.

Although the authors make a detailed and strong argument about the role waivers play within Hennepin’s court system, the paper fails to draw a strong gap between the focused group of waivers in Hennepin and waivers throughout Minnesota and the United States. The authors of this study can strengthen their article by providing increased portraits of the judges and offenders. These details will most likely lead to a better understanding of the effect waivers have on influencing sentencing decisions and recidivism of youth offenders.

BibliographyPodkopacz, Marcy Rasmussen, Feld, Barry C. The end of the line: An empirical study of judicial waiver. Journal of Criminal Law & Criminology, 86(2), 449-493.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Should juveniles be waivered to adult court Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1539441-should-juveniles-be-waivered-to-adult-court
(Should Juveniles Be Waivered to Adult Court Essay)
https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1539441-should-juveniles-be-waivered-to-adult-court.
“Should Juveniles Be Waivered to Adult Court Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1539441-should-juveniles-be-waivered-to-adult-court.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Should juveniles be waivered to adult court

Reading reflection juvies

This is made possible through the process of waiver, where the judge allows the prosecutor to transfer the juvenile case to an adult court (Marcovitz, 2012).... There are a number of disadvantages and advantages of transferring a juvenile to an adult court.... However, the disadvantages outweigh the advantages of transferring the juveniles to an adult court system.... In an adult court, chances are high that juveniles will get a harsher punishment, in comparison to the punishment they would get in a juvenile court....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Special offenders

In the case of adults, the main aim is never to rehabilitate the offender as adults are sanctioned by the court of law in compliance with the severity of their crime.... Last category of offenders are Juveniles remanded to superior court, their crimes are highly sever in nature and may be regarded as unfit to be adjudicated and they may be tried in the court of law as an adult offender is.... adult Justice Process Different states have different rules and regulations regarding juvenile and adult process of justice....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Time Served for Juveniles Transferred to Criminal Court

Accordingly, there was a need for replication of multivariate studies to determine which characteristics of juveniles who were waived to adult criminal court were robust predictors of sentencing outcomes and length of time served" (2005).... f 102 juveniles in this rural area, ninety-eight percent we waived to adult criminal court.... More significant, there was evidence to suggest that juveniles waived to adult criminal courts actually were treated with more lenience....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Colorado Juvenile Court Law

The laws of Colorado offer limited chance of a juvenile being rehabilitated and returned to society as a productive citizen after being transferred to adult court.... n conclusion, there are legitimate considerations to be weighed when deciding whether to transfer a juvenile to adult court.... This mandates that the courts and criminal justice system have a provision within the juvenile system that allows for transferring a child's case to adult criminal court....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Juveniles' Competence to Stand Trial

The third type is a unit in trial court where trials against the child are adjudicated.... uvenile courts are very much different from adult courts.... Juvenile courts proceeding are less formal and private unlike adult courts where proceedings and hearings should be followed in a formal and public.... They were treated as juveniles.... juveniles' competence to stand trial: A comparison of adolescents' and adults' capacities as trial defendants....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Felds Idea to Completely Abolish the Juvenile Courts

The recommendations that Barry Feld offers in regards to not abolishing juvenile courts involve creating a juvenile court that is separate from the current criminal court or by transforming the juvenile court into something more, something along the lines of a social welfare… These recommendations take the place of ridding entirely of the juvenile court system and subjected criminal youths to the existing court system that deals with of-age offenders. However, Feld dismisses these other options because he feels Juvenile Courts The recommendations that Barry Feld offers in regards to not abolishing juvenile courts involve creating a juvenile court that is separate from the current criminal court or by transforming the juvenile court into something more, something along the lines of a social welfare agency that caters to youthful criminals....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Ethical dilemmas and the law

Prosecuting lawyers should have their own set of ethical standards to avoid instances, when a defendant will be convicted of a crime he or she never committed (Tucker, 2012).... However, at some point, the criminal justice system may be used not to prosecute the accused, but to plotting revenge against enemies who have inflicted hatred and shame to one's memory....
7 Pages (1750 words) Research Paper

Juvenile Court Process

David Mikhail describes the Texas juvenile justice system and noted that it is not rehabilitating but severely punishing juvenile delinquents, by employing transfers to adult criminal courts.... Almost 50 years after this case, the court introduced judicial and legislative reforms to advance the rights of children to fair justice system processes.... The Supreme court stressed the importance of the “constitutional domestication of the juvenile court” by requiring all states to provide particular procedural rights to juveniles and their families, which is aligned with their constitutional rights (Ross 426)....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us