StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Recognition Animal Rights by Society - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
This essay "Recognition Animal Rights by Society" discusses the ethical treatment of animals and the question of protection of their rights arising, and argues on this basis that the rights of animals should be recognized and they should be treated on par with humans…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91% of users find it useful
Recognition Animal Rights by Society
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Recognition Animal Rights by Society"

But in the context of pain suffered by animals, Gallistel (1989) has advocated the unrestricted use of animals for research purposes, especially in the study of the nervous system. He points out that studies on the nervous system may involve the destruction or stimulation of a part of the system to examine the ramifications of the use of certain drugs and could cause pain and temporary distress to the animals used. He argues that restricting research on animals would restrict the progress in human understanding of the nervous system. It would interfere with the process of providing a moral and scientific basis for the amassing of knowledge that produces tangible benefits for the nervous ailments of humans and benefits in treatment. He contends that the suffering of a few animals cannot be accorded greater importance than the benefits that are provided to the human race. It is also argued that since animals do not possess a sense of moral values and reason, they are inferior beings as compared to humans, and therefore, their interests must be subordinated to that of human beings.

In a similar vein, H Tristam Englehardt Jr believes that “morality is a human construct and that secular moral authority is grounded in consent…[and he]…..claims that animals have "rights" granted them by humans (since only humans are "ends in themselves"), but the "rights" so granted are to be used for human welfare, including the "right" to be hunted, skinned, eaten, used for entertainment, etc” (Haack, 2007). Hence, Gallistel and Englehardt are of the view that animals may have rights, but those rights are to be subordinated to those of humans and the animals can only enjoy rights to the extent that humans permit them to have those rights. Therefore, even in instances where they suffer pain, this pain is justified on the basis that their rights are inferior to those of human beings who will benefit from the fruits of medical research experiments conducted on animals.

Bentham (2002) however offers the view that animal pain is as real as human pain and the ability to suffer must be the determinant of how we treat other beings. He argues that using the criterion of reason and ability to make moral decisions to determine the less equal treatment to animals would mean that beings like babies and the disabled would also be treated badly. The manner in which they are treated should not be dependent upon whether they can reason or talk, but whether they suffer.

In her poem “The Fish” Elizabeth Bishop writes eloquently about the veteran fish she catches, which has five fishing hooks embedded in its “aching jaw”. While her initial reaction to the fish is one of slight distaste, the sight of those hooks stirs her admiration and sympathy. The veteran fish has to live with the pain of those hooks permanently embedded into its jaw, because of the greed of men to catch them. The reality of the suffering of the animal is what prompts her to let the fish go rather than allow it to die because she is loath to cause more suffering to the fish as she watches its gills fighting for breath.

Gendin (1989) questions the value of scientific research on the basis that different species may react differently for different doses, likewise, animals cannot describe their experiences, nor can they provide information on symptoms such as giddiness or nausea. Animals undoubtedly suffer during medical research experiments; for example, Segliman (1974) has written about dogs involved in animal research experiments that were subjected to repeated shocks and became very depressed as a result, resulting in both physical and mental helplessness of the animal.

A report on the use of monkeys in medical research concludes that “in some cases, there is a valid scientific argument for the use of monkeys in medical research.” (Weatherall, 2007). The argument that pain is caused to animals is a valid one, since animals may also have rights that cannot be ignored simply on the basis that they are not moral creatures and cannot reason.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Should Society recognize animal rights, even to the extent of Essay”, n.d.)
Should Society recognize animal rights, even to the extent of Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1542501-should-society-recognize-animal-rights-even-to-the-extent-of-disallowing-the-use-of-animals-in-scientific-and-medical-experiments
(Should Society Recognize Animal Rights, Even to the Extent of Essay)
Should Society Recognize Animal Rights, Even to the Extent of Essay. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1542501-should-society-recognize-animal-rights-even-to-the-extent-of-disallowing-the-use-of-animals-in-scientific-and-medical-experiments.
“Should Society Recognize Animal Rights, Even to the Extent of Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1542501-should-society-recognize-animal-rights-even-to-the-extent-of-disallowing-the-use-of-animals-in-scientific-and-medical-experiments.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Recognition Animal Rights by Society

PETA ( People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals)

Introduction to People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals (PETA) People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals, popularly known as PETA, was founded in 1980, by the efforts and collaboration of two much experienced and dedicated animal rights activists, Ingrid Newkirk and Alex Pacheco.... PETA claims to be the biggest animal rights organization in the world.... Framing of the animal rights Issue by PETA The animal rights groups that existed before PETA were predominantly conservative, whose approach towards the issue was at the best, mild and reconciliatory....
4 Pages (1000 words) Research Paper

Rights for the Non-human Animals

The issue of animal rights involve many legal dilemmas about the direction of changes in the law.... Scarcity and socialisation are the basic themes which Inglehart follows in defining the attitude change towards animal rights.... Pluhar, Paola Cavalieri, Mark Rowlands and Gary Francione have made critical contributions to the cause of animal rights.... The issue of animal rights involve many legal dilemmas about the direction of changes in the law, the degree of animal welfare must be sought, animal suffering-reduction, compulsory animal rights education and the nature of proto-rights for all animals....
13 Pages (3250 words) Essay

Animal Rights - Michael Vick

#591304 animal rights Introduction It is not unusual that man and other animals would be seen together, or even be living together, if one explores evolution or creation.... In the United States, these animal rights are enshrined in a number of laws and statutes that ensure protection to animals and that prosecute individuals who are involved in animal abuse.... Which is why for all the valuable things animals could do for mankind, man or at least a great majority of human beings, have thought to also accord animals similar rights as human beings....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

The Ethics of Eating Animals

There is a great incongruity created by the inconsistency between the love for animals and the enjoyment of meat, raising concerns for animal's rights activists who have to contend with the fact that despite claiming to love animals, most people still enjoy meat.... There is a great incongruity created by the inconsistency between the love for animals and the enjoyment of meat, raising concerns for animal's rights activists who have to contend with the fact that despite claiming to love animals, most people still enjoy meat....
5 Pages (1250 words) Research Paper

Effective Ways to Prevent Animal Abuse

Effective Ways to Prevent Animal Abuse Institution Date Animal abuse is among the most prevalent problems that have come to take place in the modern world and this is because of the fact that in many countries, the local populations do not recognize animal rights.... In addition, it is imperative that all individuals in the society learn that all animals have rights and if their locality does not have Humane Law enforcement agents, then it is their duty to ensure that they report instances of animal abuse to the police....
6 Pages (1500 words) Research Paper

Attitudes Toward Animal Research Among Psychology Students

he issues regarding animal rights are just one aspect of respect for all the living organisms of Mother Earth.... 2Peter Singer, a prominent animal rights activist has argued that"If a being suffers, there can be no moral justification for refusing to take that suffering into consideration.... his essay discusses the rights of animals in the modern times.... The blatant and abhorrent obliviousness with which we exploit animal's poses a threat not only to their survival but any further imbalance in nature will start the downfall of mankind itself....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Animal Law Definition

This paper discusses from the perspective of animals used in scientific research, the question that is proposed to be examined is 'Should animal rights be legally recognized and should the legislative provisions be modified to include this aspect?... On the other hand, animal rights are the idea that all animals are entitled to certain rights because they also possess moral rights.... Animal welfare is concerned with mitigating cruelty to animals but the motive behind preventing cruelty is not because an animal has specific moral rights....
15 Pages (3750 words) Research Paper

Aspects of Animals Rights and Michael Vick Case

In the United States, these animal rights are enshrined in a number of laws and statutes that ensure protection to animals and that prosecute individuals who are involved in animal abuse.... This coursework "Aspects of Animals rights and Michael Vick Case" demonstrates lessons from the Vick case, describes the Animal Welfare Act dated to 1966.... his is why for all the valuable things animals could do for mankind, man or at least a great majority of human beings, have thought to also accord animals similar rights as human beings....
6 Pages (1500 words) Coursework
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us