StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Analysis of the film Gattaca in reference to its discussion about eugenics and getenics engineering - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Running Head: GATTACA ANALYSIS Analysis of the film Gattaca in reference to its discussion about eugenics and genetic engineering Analysis of the film Gattaca in reference to its discussion about eugenics and genetic engineering The film Gattaca (1997) presents a moral dilemma as it explores a world in which genetic selection has created races of people in which some are considered better and put into a higher social class than those who are conceived naturally…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.2% of users find it useful
Analysis of the film Gattaca in reference to its discussion about eugenics and getenics engineering
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Analysis of the film Gattaca in reference to its discussion about eugenics and getenics engineering"

Download file to see previous pages

However, despite a very firm belief that any attempt at perfecting the human condition through selectively engineering children will have a detrimental effect on the human species, it is undeniable that if allowed, I would go back and have things corrected. It is in this desire to be perfected and saved, balanced against the detriment to society that supports the idea that legislation must prevent this from being a part of reproductive options. The concept of eugenics is defined by Francis Galton, British eugenicist and scientist, as “science that studies all the influences that may potentially effect reproduction, with the purpose of preventing degeneration and attaining the improvement of the human species” (Lavrin, 1998, p. 161). While the concept of eugenics seems to be defined by a pure intent, the central problem with eugenics is that it weeds out diversities and challenges that inspire human innovation.

Morris (2006) states that “Another fear about this new eugenics is that we might one day breed a race of clones designed genetically to be placid slaves. In this very frightening scenario, eugenics is envisioned as a tool to suppress people” (p. 70). Gattaca takes this fear one step further as those without genetic enhancement are subjugated to lower level job positions, serving those who are of a genetically superior make-up. Vincent is considered an in-valid, his genetic make-up not fitting into the standard that has been set for the upper class, meanwhile his social class does not allow him the opportunities that he desires.

His life expectancy, as determined at the time of his birth, is only 30.2 years and the list of potential problems, none of which is guaranteed, is vast and daunting. There is no doubt that this type of predictability about the future of the potential outcomes would be disheartening and place that child within a social framework that was undesirable. This is what happens to Vincent, but as an adult he determines to write his own fate. Through impersonating someone with a better genetic code, he proves that he is valuable enough to achieve his goals.

The director of the film, Andrew Niccol, who also wrote the piece, provides his beliefs on genetic engineering a forum through the film. One of the first lines of narration, “They used to say that a child conceived in love has a greater chance of happiness. They don’t say that anymore” provides the context on how social and cultural class divisions had changed the nature of predicted futures for the people within the universe of the film (Niccol, 1997). In the contrast between Vincent and the wheelchair ridden ’perfected’ human, Jerome, the aspect of chance shows that expected life expectancies and the use of genetic manipulation to ’perfect’ the human species will never account for the challenges that chance will put in the way of ambitions and desires.

Vincent narrates that “He suffered under a different burden: the burden of perfection” (Niccol, 1997). Niccol uses this theme to frame his position on the danger of genetically engineering children. The character of Irene, an almost perfect who is

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Analysis of the film Gattaca in reference to its discussion about Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1425320-philosophical-paper-the-moive-gattaca
(Analysis of the Film Gattaca in Reference to Its Discussion about Essay)
https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1425320-philosophical-paper-the-moive-gattaca.
“Analysis of the Film Gattaca in Reference to Its Discussion about Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1425320-philosophical-paper-the-moive-gattaca.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Analysis of the film Gattaca in reference to its discussion about eugenics and getenics engineering

Eugenics: Economics for the Long Run

In his essay "eugenics: Economics For the Long Run", Dr Edward Miller proposes a system of eugenics for those members of the population that are living on welfare, or who have committed crimes such as rape or other violent crimes.... hellip; However, with eugenics' past history as a tool of repressive governments and its image as a coercive tool, is there any way in which a democratic government would be able to utilise eugenics....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Sci-Fi Movie Called Gattaca

This is society trying to produce perfect citizens, something that is not in the nature of man and abhorring and discriminating citizens that do not come up to its standards and ex.... hellip; Thus, this new kind of eugenics, that produce genetically engineered creatures that society deems worthy and valuable is the root cause of society's discrimination of its citizens who did not undergo this bizarre reproductive technology.... This 1997 sci-fi movie is a futuristic film about a society playing God and meddling with nature by controlling man's DNA makeup to produce genetically modified citizens, possessing the most superlative hereditary traits of their parents....
9 Pages (2250 words) Movie Review

There Is No Gene for the Human Spirit

This film from writer/director Andrew Niccol is an extraordinary look into eugenics, and genetic engineering in the near future.... When the two team leaders for both sectors where interviewed about the future of human engineering and specifically about "Designer babies" by paying customers, they both laughed in unison and responded; "Mostly what people want is offspring who are good looking smart, talented in one way or another and easy to get along with.... Supported later in the late 19 th century it became a serious scientific study then failing as a science in WWII when Nazis used eugenics to support the extermination of entire races, arising then severe ethical questions regarding "the survival of the fittest....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Where is the Good in Eugenics

This paper will look at several topics concerning eugenics and what the practice might mean in the present day and future.... The term "eugenics" comes from the Greek for "good genetics," and, when applied to human beings, describes any sort of method used to control the genetics of an individual or a population of individuals for the greater good of the society.... The definition encompasses As quoted in "Regulating eugenics," Francis Galton—who was actually a cousin of Charles Darwin—first used the term "eugenics" in 1883....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Analysis of the movie Gattaca

The ethical dilemma and interpretations that surrounds the film gattaca, however, are numerous.... the film directed by Niccol displays a society where that uses the knowledge of eugenics in reproduction.... the film bases its intention between the These derived names represent individuals with certain genome.... This is the basis of genetic discrimination that the film depicts.... The main character in the film is Vincent who is an invalid....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Ugenics Revisited - Genetic Engineering

The concept of natural selection and genetic engineering is same i.... The only difference is that natural selection is a nature's ultimate process while the genetic engineering is an optional and artificial process, which anyone can choose on his own opinion (Bradshaw, 2006).... Genetic engineering is very vast field as it includes many of the gene mutations e.... All of these gene mutations come under the head of genetic engineering, which is different from natural selection in this regard....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Summary of Gattaca Movie

This is society trying to produce perfect citizens, something that is not in the nature of man and abhorring and discriminating citizens that do not come up to its standards and ex.... nbsp; Thus, this new kind of eugenics, that produce genetically engineered creatures that society deems worthy and valuable is the root cause of society's discrimination of its citizens who did not undergo this bizarre reproductive technology.... The paper "Summary of gattaca Movie" discusses that cloning and all such attempts to tamper nature and God's will had been with us for decades....
9 Pages (2250 words) Movie Review

Prenatal Testing for Disabilities is Eugenics

llot and Neumayr discusses the issue of eugenics and prenatal tests at a neutral point of view; they neither recommend the tests nor do they oppose them.... While many believe that these tests are a great advancement in both science and medicine, others believe that this is another form of eugenics.... This article uses credible evidence from surveys, researchers, and experts in the field of eugenics.... This article proves that prenatal diagnosis is eugenics, no matter what the experts say....
6 Pages (1500 words) Annotated Bibliography
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us