StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Can the Existence of God be Proven Ontologically - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Can the Existence of God be Proven Ontologically? The subject of religion and more so, the existence of God, is always a sensitive topic, this might be because it is the very core of human life. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.7% of users find it useful
Can the Existence of God be Proven Ontologically
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Can the Existence of God be Proven Ontologically"

Download file to see previous pages

One of such theories is the ontological argument; in this paper I will argue that this theory is not enough to prove the existence of God. The ontological argument is priori; it seeks to explain the existence of a greater being using logic as to what the appreciative of the superior being that is God is. The theory was popularized by Anselm who used psalms 14 as his reference point and addressed the fool who says in his heart that God does not exist. He states that the fool hears and understands that there is a greater being although he does not understand its existence.

Anselm purports that if it exists in one’s understanding then it can be made to exist in reality, which carries more weight. He clearly states that God is a being without which nothing greater exists and the fool understands this but does not believe that God does truly exist. Anselm’s theory is more or less based on deduction if the fool understands that a greater being does exist then it must exist, otherwise he would be contradicting himself. This theory is unsatisfactory in proving God’s existence since it claims that assuming that God does not exist leads to a contradiction, He must therefore exist.

The theory seems to dictate that God does exist by the virtue that He must exist, since nothing greater can be conceived than Him, it illustrates that God’s existence is necessary since the thought of Him not existing is inconceivable. The idea that the existence of God is necessary does not proof that He actually exists; it is more like forcing an issue down someone’s throat and expecting that person to believe it and accept it as the truth. Because He carries the title God, the theory then seems to insinuate that it s wrong to claim that God does not exist.

For something to exist, the concept must correspond to reality, but Anselm’s theory is based on abstract facts and this does not proof that a greater being does exist. A monk by the name Gaunilo, also attempted to refute the claims by Anselm describing an island that can be said to be ore excellent than any other existing island. He goes ahead to argue that an island that that exists is much better than a non-existent one, so therefore the island must exist by definition. The assumption that one can define anything that he wants and it will exist corresponds to the ontological theory.

It would be therefore correct to assume that the devil also exists by the necessity that he must. Since God does exist and he is all good and presumably much greater than conceived then the devil must also exist as that which nothing worse can be conceived. This theory therefore holds no water and does not prove God’s existence since it would then show that one can imagine and assume anything in life and it shall be a reality which is not the case. Alvin Plantiga also decided to remodel the ontological argument by use of logic, claiming that concepts must either be necessary, impossible or possible.

In his concepts, he claims that there is a world that possibly exists with a being that is maximally great, meaning that He exists in all possible worlds and therefore must exist in our world as well. This argument has no much difference from the Anselm’s argument because what it does is state that the greater being is a possibility. This claim is debatable meaning that it does not have any tangible proof to support its basis. The ontological argument clearly shows that God only survives in the mind, which means if God is imagined and a creation of the mind, then something greater than God can be imagined.

But one should not forget that this is all in the mind and not actually existing in real

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Can the Existence of God be Proven Ontologically Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1480088-can-the-existence-of-god-be-proven-ontologically
(Can the Existence of God Be Proven Ontologically Essay)
https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1480088-can-the-existence-of-god-be-proven-ontologically.
“Can the Existence of God Be Proven Ontologically Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1480088-can-the-existence-of-god-be-proven-ontologically.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Can the Existence of God be Proven Ontologically

Cosmological Proof of Gods Existence

This paper ''Cosmological Proof of god's Existence'' tells that The 13th-century saint and philosopher Thomas Aquinas have laid the foundation of the cosmological proof of god's existence as the First Uncaused Cause.... god is known as the Creator of the universe and only fitting to regard Him as the First Cause.... hellip; According to the Cosmological Argument of Thomas Aquinas, god is the First and Uncaused Cause.... He does this while somehow postulating that only god can cause Itself to exist....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

The Four Arguments for the Existence of God

The four arguments for the existence of god are ontological, which is when God exists if we can argue and conceive this, if we base our feelings of his existence off of intuition; cosmological, which is the belief that for the universe to exist as it does, then there must have… en a God that had created it; teleological, which is when people believe that God exist because of an order and the details of a creation, such as human lives; and the moral argument, which states that there could be no morality without God....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Issues on the Existence of God

The essay "Issues on the existence of god" discusses why would an intelligent mind believe or not believe in the existence of god, and what the author's opinion about the nature and existence of God is.... The topic of the debate was the existence of god based upon the atheistic views that Dawkins presented in his book, The God Delusion.... Christianity poses dangers to the existence of humans as all wars and destructions come as a result of the religious beliefs and differences in faiths....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Critical Evaluation of Descartes Principle of Proofs of Existence of God

Descartes gives two arguments for the existence of god.... In his ontological arguments, Descartes gives two arguments about the existence of god.... He sets to prove the existence of god in these two arguments.... An essay "Critical Evaluation of Descartes Principle of Proofs of existence of god" claims that Descartes studies about God were to show that God is not a deceiver, and he aims to bring a clear perception in our minds....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

The nature of Ontological arguments for Gods existence

hellip; Ontological arguments for the existence of god are based on reason rather than observation.... Ontological arguments do not look for the physical evidence to show the existence of god.... Most ontological arguments use this approach to explain the concept of the existence of god.... Despite this, the ontological augments go on to show how they can deduce the existence of god from the definition of God.... An example of an ontological argument is the having views that the existence of god to be absurd as the four-sided triangle or existence of the married bachelor....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

The Question of Gods Existence

The author of "The Question of God's Existence" paper analyzes the various arguments that prove the existence of god, including arguments put forward by St.... Thomas Aquinas, while also examining a few counter-arguments that disprove the existence of god.... hellip; Some philosophers and scientists have questioned the existence of god and put forward several arguments to support their view that God does not exist.... In order to appreciate the arguments for or against the existence of god, it is important to understand the meaning of God....
9 Pages (2250 words) Coursework

Teleological Arguments for the Existence of God

"Teleological Arguments for the existence of god" paper seeks to contend through the teleological philosophical argument that God does actually exists and to this end, it examines some of the major arguments that have been posited in support of his presence.... To some, the existence of god is axiomatic; they base their argument of faith and claim that those who oppose them do so from spiritual ignorance and naivety.... Conversely, teleological arguments have proven more convincing; these are arguments that based their proof of god's existence on the fact that the universe is full of evidence of an intelligent creator....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Anselm's Ontological Argument for the Existence of God

This paper ''Anselm's Ontological Argument for the existence of god'' tells that Anselm's argument for Gods existence is one of the most debated arguments for the existence of god (Geisler, 1976, 89).... Gaunilo of Marmoutier was basing his attack on Anselms ontological argument on the basis that the Anselms argument for the existence of god is based on the fact that it would be absurd to conclude that God does not exist if first of all he is the most perfect being that can be conceived to exist, and yet a most perfect being, a being than which no greater being can exist, must exist in order to be most perfect....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us