StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Unwritten Checks and Balances of the UK and USA - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "Unwritten Checks and Balances of the UK and USA" states that the checks and balances of the UK allow the judiciary to decide on the genuineness of an act while according to the USA’s checks and balances the judicial arm of the government only interprets the law…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.8% of users find it useful
Unwritten Checks and Balances of the UK and USA
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Unwritten Checks and Balances of the UK and USA"

One of the differences between the UK’s unwritten checks and balances and the USA’s written checks and balances is flexibility. U.K’s unwritten checks and balances are easy to change and revise in order to address emerging needs. On the other hand, USA’s written checks and balances are relatively rigid and require long and procedural actions to change or review. That notwithstanding, USA’s written checks and balances have the advantage of quick reference since they are contained in a single document. Conversely, UK’s unwritten checks and balances are difficult because they are contained in different documents (Hauss 458).
UK’s unwritten checks and balances ascribe the legislature with sovereignty and other judicial bodies do not object to the statutes that result from the legislature. In a way, this gives the government seemingly unconstrained power because the majority party has the power to pass many bills. USA’s written checks and balances are different because they are codified and this gives them authority. These checks and balances limit and bind all political institutions and establish a hierarchy of law. USA’s political institutions are subjected to judicial review, the judiciary can override a decision by the executive, and the executive can veto a decision made by the legislature (Hauss 459).
UK’s unwritten checks and balances recognize the powers of the monarch as a fourth arm of the government in the UK. For example, the queen can dissolve or refuse to dissolve the parliament during an emergency. On the other hand, USA’s written checks and balances recognize the judiciary, legislature, and executive as the three arms of government. The checks and balances provide that only the executive can force the legislature to adjourn. UK’s unwritten checks and balances provide that a judges’ council appoints senior judicial elements. Conversely, USA’s written checks and balances task the executive with the role of appointing judges that the legislature approves (Hauss 460).
The unwritten checks and balances of the UK stipulate that courts can decide whether a document is a genuine Act. Different from this stipulation, USA’s checks and balances allow the judicial arm of government to interpret the law. UK’s unwritten checks and balance allows the Lord Chancellor to impeach judges while according to USA’s checks and balances, the legislature can impeach judges. UK’s unwritten checks and balances stipulate that the House of the Lords be not democratically elected whereas USA’s written checks and balances explain that members of both houses of the Congress are democratically elected. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Difference between the USA and UK government type and the difference Essay”, n.d.)
Difference between the USA and UK government type and the difference Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/social-science/1645036-difference-between-the-usa-and-uk-government-type-and-the-difference-in-the-checks-and-balances-uk-unwritten-checks-and-balances-list-usa-written-checks-and-balances
(Difference Between the USA and UK Government Type and the Difference Essay)
Difference Between the USA and UK Government Type and the Difference Essay. https://studentshare.org/social-science/1645036-difference-between-the-usa-and-uk-government-type-and-the-difference-in-the-checks-and-balances-uk-unwritten-checks-and-balances-list-usa-written-checks-and-balances.
“Difference Between the USA and UK Government Type and the Difference Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/social-science/1645036-difference-between-the-usa-and-uk-government-type-and-the-difference-in-the-checks-and-balances-uk-unwritten-checks-and-balances-list-usa-written-checks-and-balances.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Unwritten Checks and Balances of the UK and USA

Why do Youth Commit Offence

A child is not born as a criminal or an offender; circumstances force him to become one (Weiner 242).... Quoting Morrison, Weiner (242) further explains that that the surroundings in which a man is born and forced to live, shape him.... .... ... ... How do YOTs attempt to balance their responsibilities for child welfare and crime control?...
13 Pages (3250 words) Essay

The British Constitution

After the accession of the uk to European Economic Community, European common law has gained preeminence in the UK which is inevitable.... The establishment of European Court of Justice and its growing significance in the legal system of the United Kingdom and the supremacy of EC law in the event of conflicts with the uk laws have caused a great deal of discussions and... In countries like the usa whose democratic origin has been very recent, writing constitution for a new country after their independence from British rule was a necessity....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Corporate Governance frameworks

the uk and usa Corporate Governance frameworks are predicated on fundamentally different approaches to principal/stakeholder protection, one being rules-based, the other principles-based.... Corporate governance scandals in the uk and US, during the period of 1990-1992 Page 6 5.... This report aims to critically compare the uk and US systems of corporate governance, where this term is more narrowly defined as relating to the accountability of decision makers, and excludes from consideration the role of corporate governance in increasing organisational efficiency....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Unwritten Constitution

6 The jurist and legal historian, Lord Hailsham believes that a written constitution is not necessary pointing out that: "The essential ingredientsare a strong executive based on an omnicompetent and elective legislatureregular electionspowerful and independent oppositionand limitedby convention and precedentand regulated more by checks and balances deriving from political constraints and necessities than by a written legal code policed by a Supreme Court.... However, commentators in the uk prefer a wider definition....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Impact of US Credit Crunch on Global Economy

The credit crunch in usa is sparked by sub-prime mortgage in which loans for housing were sanctioned by banks to large number of borrowers having shady credit worthiness, which ran the highest risk of defaulting.... he housing boom started in usa in the year 2000.... There were millions of sub-prime mortgages in usa with reports of about two million of them expected to lose homes to foreclosure according to Pittman 2007.... Global economy will have negative repurcussions of the credit crunch in usa....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

How Many Checks and Balances the British Government Labours Under

To determine how few or how many checks and balances the British government labours under, and whether they have increased or decreased over the years, it is necessary to note the special features of the British democracy.... arenthetically, checks and balances are a lot more than mere separation of powers: the essence of the latter is autonomy for every branch, which can only ensure that one branch of the government does not poach on the particular preserves of endeavour of any other....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

The British Constitution

After the accession of the uk to European Economic Community, European common law has gained preeminence in the UK which is inevitable.... In countries like the usa whose democratic origin has been very recent, writing constitution for a new country after their independence from British rule was a necessity.... But, parliamentary democracy in Britain has a very long history and the Parliament of uk is one of the oldest democratic institutions in the world....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

The Hong Kong Basic Law in Comparison With the Constitutions of Other Countries

We thus might at that most unfortunate time, behold a possible exodus of Hong Kong citizens reminiscent of the pre-1997 hegira of its citizens to such countries as Canada, the USA and the uk.... n 1842, the Qing Dynasty was compelled by uk's victory in the First Opium War to cede Hong Kong Island to Britain in perpetuity....
20 Pages (5000 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us