StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Views of Tom Regan on Animal Rights as Compared to the Utilitarian View of Animal Rights - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "Views of Tom Regan on Animal Rights as Compared to the Utilitarian View of Animal Rights" argues that both views on animal rights have a different approach as Regan talks about the moral rights that non-human animals have because they are subject-of-a-life…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.7% of users find it useful
Views of Tom Regan on Animal Rights as Compared to the Utilitarian View of Animal Rights
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Views of Tom Regan on Animal Rights as Compared to the Utilitarian View of Animal Rights"

Regan gave the philosophy of animal rights in his famous book The Case for Animal Rights (1983). This book greatly influenced the animal rights movement as Regan argued that non-human animals are also “subjects of a life” just as all other humans (Regan, 2004). According to his theory, when value is given to all other humans regardless of their mental and rational abilities then the same value should be ascribed to non-human animals as well. His arguments are based on the views of Immanuel Kant that all animals have moral rights but he criticizes Kant’s belief that only rational beings are subjected to respect.

Regan rejects this view and argues that humans gain value and respect regardless of their rationality as with infants and those who are mentally unstable thus non-human animals are also subjected to the same value and respect regardless of their rationality. Since all human and non-human animals are subjects-of-a-life, life is the only attribute that would be subject to value. Thus every being that is subject to life must be treated with respect and must be given moral rights (Regan, 2004).

On the other hand, utilitarianism is a theory that proposes that any action will be morally right only when it benefits and provides good to a large number of people. According to this theory, what’s right is determined by the value of pleasure or pain that it causes to other people. If an action causes pleasure to most people then it is considered morally right while if it causes pain and suffering for the people, it will be considered morally wrong. Utilitarianism is often used to justify animal rights as their pain and pleasure are also counted for actions that are morally right or wrong (Brooman, 1997).

Utilitarian theorists believe that biologically it is justified that non-human animals are sentient and biologically they can feel pain and pleasure. This is justified also practically as many people have experienced such feelings in animals, especially cats, and dogs. There is a lot of evidence that non-human animals are sentient and they feel pain. Biologically and behaviorally, non-human animals have the capabilities to respond to pain and pleasure-seeking situations. This is why utilitarianism argues that non-human animals are also subjected to moral duties and people have to ensure that their actions are causing pleasure not only to humans but also to non-human animals (Brooman, 1997).

The utilitarianism view, however, argues that non-human animals are biologically and behaviorally subjected to pain and pleasure which is why an action would be considered morally right if it is beneficial for all human and non-human animals combined.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Animal right Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words”, n.d.)
Animal right Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/social-science/1655699-animal-right
(Animal Right Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words)
Animal Right Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words. https://studentshare.org/social-science/1655699-animal-right.
“Animal Right Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/social-science/1655699-animal-right.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Views of Tom Regan on Animal Rights as Compared to the Utilitarian View of Animal Rights

Philosophy: Animal Rights

Author Tutor Course Date animal rights Introduction Animals have made contribution immensely in the human society since the beginning of civilization.... This paper seeks to defend animal rights against Cohen's argument that animals have absolutely no rights.... Animals too have essential rights although, not as equally detailed, compared to human rights since there is a difference between obligations and rights, obligation being what we ought to do and rights being what others can demand from us....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Ethical Issues Involved in Animal Testing

As disclosed, Peter Singer, an Australian philosopher and a writer of animal Liberation, allegedly supported the utilitarian theory which espoused that “in all decisions the total amount of good that results—human and animal—should be weighed against the suffering—human and animal—caused in the process.... As disclosed, Peter Singer, an Australian philosopher and a writer of animal Liberation, allegedly supported the utilitarian theory which espoused that 'in all decisions the total amount of good that results—human and animal—should be weighed against the suffering—human and animal—caused in the process....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Should Animals Have Their Own Rights

The points explained through the paper include that under the issue of predation and eating meat, a guardian farmer of a domesticated animal holds the right to slaughter it for meat or trade it for money and the goodness of humans as compared to the cruelty of the wild, bestows extra rights on the human than the animal.... The author of the reprot talks about Alan Holland's review of animal rights which depicts depth and richness, making it a helpful tool in solving disputes and practical problems....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Animal Rights: Is It Morally Wrong to Eat Meat

The human beings have a higher value as compared to animals on account of their potential and abilities and the quality of life that they lead.... The movement for animal rights, which is also known as animal liberation, is the concept that the basic interests of animals should be regarded with an equal eye as with humans.... In Tom Regan's case for animal rights, he speaks about how animals have moral rights and if due respect is given to human beings who are not rational, such as infants or mentally challenged people, then animals should not be deprived of this right just because they cannot make rational decisions for themselves....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Dickens's Treatment of Education and Social Mobility in Hard Times

It pays no tribute to civilisation, culture or refinement, everything in it is "severely workful" and utilitarian.... Hard Times" is the portrait of a rapidly changing society in the grasp of forces it has unleashed upon itself.... Written in 1854, the novel depicts the various forces shaping Victorian England and how this affected social structure and mobility as well as education....
18 Pages (4500 words) Essay

Animal Law Definition

Drug testing carried on in animals is intended to examine the safety of these drugs prior to their use in humans, since human life is perceived as more precious as compared to an animal.... This paper discusses from the perspective of animals used in scientific research, the question that is proposed to be examined is 'Should animal rights be legally recognized and should the legislative provisions be modified to include this aspect?... On the other hand, animal rights are the idea that all animals are entitled to certain rights because they also possess moral rights....
15 Pages (3750 words) Research Paper

Ethical Treatment of Animals and Animal Rights

The paper "Ethical Treatment of Animals and animal rights " states that while animals may not be capable of the levels of complex moral thinking and reasoning that human beings are capable of, nevertheless as Regan has argued, they are capable of feeling pain and sharing cognitive abilities.... animal rights are the idea that all animals are entitled to certain rights because they also possess moral rights, as a result of which those rights should be recognized within the framework of the law....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Modern Concern for the Animal Rights

Thereby, to arrive at a definitive view regarding the issue of animal rights, it is imperative to give due and concerted consideration to the pros and cons associated with this issue.... he supporters of animal rights do extend the argument that animals by virtue of sentient beings do have an innate and inherent worth (Guither 48).... Such supporters of animal rights hold that animals do have an inherent worth no way means that animals are equal to humans, but this no way contradicts the extension of rights to the animals (Guither 48)....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us