StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Decision in Philadelphia by Christopher and James Lincoln Collier - Book Report/Review Example

Cite this document
Summary
In the paper “Decision in Philadelphia by Christopher and James Lincoln Collier,” the author discusses the book, which still remains to be one of the most popular historical writing of a momentous moment in the avalanche of US political experience…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.3% of users find it useful
Decision in Philadelphia by Christopher and James Lincoln Collier
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Decision in Philadelphia by Christopher and James Lincoln Collier"

Download file to see previous pages

A part of the book explains the importance of the Philadelphia convention of 1787 and the role it plays in the political history of the US constitution. The book covers the whole of social history, particularly in terms of ethnicity. The book offers its readers a comprehensive and brief understanding of the journey undertaken by America which transformed the country of hunters and farmers to a mightiest industrial nation existing on this earth. Undoubtedly, it could be said that the Philadelphia convention that the way Murrin has portrayed Philadelphia convention is remarkable and it explains the on-goings of that time with a not-altogether-same perspective as the Collier's Decision in Philadelphia.

(Powell's Books) Both the books hold the Philadelphia convention of 1787 in high esteem and acknowledge its importance in the successful running of the American political system. The style of describing the whole period differs in both the books in two ways. Collier goes from describing one important event to another while Murrin's style in one of describing events in chronological order. Secondly, Murrin's book is written as in a manner of teaching and narrating while Collier's 'Decision in Philadelphia' actually is a discussion of the events with the students.

The book 'Decision in Philadelphia' was published on the 200th anniversary of the Philadelphia convention and the author holds great regard for the event. Consequently, the author's approach of the personalities, events and the convention itself is one where the book regards the convention reverence rather than depicting the true account. 'Liberty, Equality and Power' however narrates the history behind the convention considering both the negative and the positive sides of the picture. This could be seen from the fact that Collier in his description of anti-federalists like George Mason in which the author has painted a negative image in the reader's mind while displaying the nationalists and as patriotic and intellectual people.

Murrin, however, adopts a neutral attitude in his description of events or people and he states the facts without confusing them with a personal opinion though in a very interesting manner. Decision in Philadelphia engages more in elaborating the feelings and emotions of the people involved in drafting the Philadelphia convention, their endeavors, meetings and finally the constitution itself while on the other hand 'Liberty, Equality and Power' gives a third-person view on the whole situation rather than putting its focus on any one personality and event.

The authors of 'Decision in Philadelphia' have somewhat given an underestimated view about the framers' commitment to the ideological notions of individual rights as well the state law. These issues are discussed in mild detail but their importance has been shadowed by the issues regarding the discussion of the politics of the Philadelphia convention. These details have been highlighted more to give an overview of the proceedings regarding the framing of the constitution. 'Liberty, Equality and Power', in contrast with 'Decision in Philadelphia' discusses these notions and ideologies in apt detail and regards.

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Decision in Philadelphia by Christopher and James Lincoln Collier Book Report/Review, n.d.)
Decision in Philadelphia by Christopher and James Lincoln Collier Book Report/Review. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/sociology/1503418-philadelphia-convention-1787
(Decision in Philadelphia by Christopher and James Lincoln Collier Book Report/Review)
Decision in Philadelphia by Christopher and James Lincoln Collier Book Report/Review. https://studentshare.org/sociology/1503418-philadelphia-convention-1787.
“Decision in Philadelphia by Christopher and James Lincoln Collier Book Report/Review”. https://studentshare.org/sociology/1503418-philadelphia-convention-1787.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Decision in Philadelphia by Christopher and James Lincoln Collier

How We Got Lincoln

How We got lincoln Peter Andrews, in his writing “How we got lincoln”, talks about the national republican convention held at Chicago in 1860.... Abraham lincoln was a candidate in 1860 elections, though he had critical arguments against it.... Manifold events happened in late 1859 and early 1860 that gave a boost to lincoln's chances in presidency.... Judd, in order to give lincoln an advantage of home city....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Abraham Lincoln's First Inaugural

One needs to reach out straightaway to the Inaugural Address Abraham lincoln delivered to the Nation on March 4, 1861 as the President of the United States, to understand the power of the Executive under the American Constitution.... hellip; One needs to reach out straightaway to the Inaugural Address Abraham lincoln delivered to the Nation on March 4, 1861 as the President of the United States, to understand the power of the Executive under the American Constitution....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

The City of Philadelphia in Pennsylvania

Student's Full Name: Professor's Name: The City of philadelphia in Pennsylvania 06 October 2013 Introduction philadelphia in Greek literally means “brotherly love” hence it is oftentimes called as the “City of Brotherly Love' while its other favorite nickname is just “Philly” to its residents.... hellip; philadelphia is located in the northeastern seaboard of the United States of America at the junction of the Delaware and Schuylkill Rivers and the largest city within the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania (latest 2012 census showed about 1....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Lincoln Electrical Company's Strategies

The writer of the paper "lincoln Electrical Company's Strategies" gives answers to questions about two strategies that lincoln Electrical Company used to ensure the competitive advantage over rivals.... Therefore lincoln ensured that it always invested in the employees to increase their productivity.... lincoln employed the classical approach in the management of its human resource.... lincoln's approach to TQM, quality control, and quality assurance was to employ an in-house strategy to ensure that the employees owned the quality control and quality assurance processes....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Was Abraham Lincoln a racist

Over the years, there has been a lot of controversy on the issue of whether Abraham lincoln was ultimately a racist or not; moreover, these has led to multiple debates like the well known lincoln- Douglas debates.... Reflectively, lincoln entered the political arena in the late… s when slavery was very popular and according to most people's opinions he would have taken or rather encountered the slave in a more disgraceful and unorthodox way i....
8 Pages (2000 words) Term Paper

Abraham Lincoln and the Civil War

In the essay “Abraham lincoln and the Civil War” the author examines the American civil war, which is a critical landmark in the history of America.... lincoln's actions resulted in the success of the civil war.... The Republicans opposed the idea of expanding slavery into the territories and aired their views through their candidate, Abraham lincoln....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Lincoln and His Generals

The study "lincoln and His Generals” explores the President's attitude towards his associates.... McClellan enjoyed a lack of lincoln's military experience, Halleck became lincoln's puppet, and only General Grant achieved a balance between self-reliance in battlefield and autonomy in civil matters....  … Abraham lincoln was a genius, since he came into office with no military knowledge, yet was possessed of an extraordinary flexibility and ability to learn from mistakes and guide the country through the Civil War....
15 Pages (3750 words) Coursework

Lincoln on Leadership

The author of this review "lincoln on Leadership" casts light on the leadership philosophy of Abraham lincoln and helpful steps on how to incorporate his principles into your own management style.... Reportedly, the book is sectioned into four parts, each tackling a different part of lincoln's philosophy.... This review concludes that whilst the book is Phillips' enthusiasm for lincoln is obvious throughout the book and the layout of information makes the book easy to read....
12 Pages (3000 words) Book Report/Review
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us