StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Skepticism and Contextualism by Ernest Sosa - Article Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper “Skepticism and Contextualism by Ernest Sosa” analyzes the article by Ernest Sosa who attempts to prove that there are some significant problems inherent in using contextualism as a means of refuting skepticism in epistemology. The author provides a brief description of epistemology…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.9% of users find it useful
Skepticism and Contextualism by Ernest Sosa
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Skepticism and Contextualism by Ernest Sosa"

By considering the context in which the statement is uttered, there are many ways in which it might be understood to be true on some level of understanding. However, the author also asserts that the need to provide context both confuses and fails to fully answer the concerns of the skeptics on the philosophical level even when the statements are true on a more common level. This is relevant to epistemology when the truth of the statement remains even when shifts in context occur from the common to the philosophical and vice versa.

In addressing the relevance of contextualism to skepticism in epistemology, the author lists the four basic types of thresholds that must be defined in order to fully answer the skeptics' concerns. These include “’ belief’: how sure must one be? … ‘justification’: how much rational support is required for one’s belief? … ‘reliability’: how reliable are one’s operative sources or faculties? … ‘safety’: how easily might one have been wrong?

” (Sosa 6). Many of these questions, of course, place the conversation, again, in the realm of contextualism even on a philosophical plane. This also illustrates the degree to which contextualism can be applied to such an extent that all meaning is rendered meaningless and the skeptics are reinforced in their argument. Instead, the author proposes that all knowledge exists on a continuum of thresholds that change for a variety of reasons and contexts and knowledge itself is something that we attain to but never reach as contexts and information continue to change or be defined.

We base our feelings of knowledge, then, on a degree of safety that what we believe is actually true. The problem with this is that, even given all the information we have available to answer the various factors described, we may still believe something to be true and thus be real knowledge when it is false because one of those variable factors is either false or has become false through accident or fluke. The author makes his point convincingly that the skeptics' argument is not fully met through the process of contextualism as this itself introduces reasons for skepticism.

The argument is difficult to follow because of the complexity of the subject and the ambiguousness of many of the examples, which must remain ambiguous as a central element of the argument.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Skepticism and Contextualism by Ernest Sosa Article, n.d.)
Skepticism and Contextualism by Ernest Sosa Article. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/sociology/1549122-philosophy-epistemology-article-skepticism-and-contextualism-by-sosa-ernest
(Skepticism and Contextualism by Ernest Sosa Article)
Skepticism and Contextualism by Ernest Sosa Article. https://studentshare.org/sociology/1549122-philosophy-epistemology-article-skepticism-and-contextualism-by-sosa-ernest.
“Skepticism and Contextualism by Ernest Sosa Article”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/sociology/1549122-philosophy-epistemology-article-skepticism-and-contextualism-by-sosa-ernest.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Skepticism and Contextualism by Ernest Sosa

Moral Skepticism

Instructor Date Moral skepticism Moral skepticism holds that no person has any moral knowledge.... It denies the objective platform of morality.... What counts as moral objective depends on an individual.... Socrates claimed that he knew nothing.... This implies that when someone is skeptical about everything, he or she should be skeptical about himself or herself....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Ernest Ludwig Kirchner

ernest Ludwig Kirchner (1880 - 1938) was a German artist, a representative of expressionism of the first half of the 20th century.... He was one of the founders of the artists group "Die Brucke" or "The Bridge.... Although the group of artists lived in a small communal atmosphere in isolation, each artist had different interests and styles perusing in terms of depicting human psych....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Cognitive vs Computational Capacities

It refers to the information processing and the application of the knowledge.... All the Cognitive activities can be artificial, natural, conscious or unconscious.... Cognitive capacities or in… The word Cognition is related to Psychology and Philosophy as well.... The terms, learning, intelligence, perception, reasoning or numerical abilities can be attributed to It can be studied as a property of brain....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Is Knowledge Closed Under Known Entailment

The epistemic closure principles in philosophy are used in countless ways.... Some of the principles have been rejected by theorists thus, remain controversial.... The paper "Is Knowledge Closed Under Known Entailment?... seeks to address the question: Is knowledge closed under known entailment....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Ernest Rutherford

Furthermore, ernest observed that radioactivity of objects reduced with time ernest Rutherford Born on August 30, 1871, Earnest Rutherford made significant contributions in the field of science, especially physics by carrying out experiments to illustrate the concept of radioactivity (BBC 1).... Furthermore, ernest observed that radioactivity of objects reduced with time (Rutherford 17).... Discovery of nuclear physics is also the basis of modern energy thus useful in my understanding of providing alternatives to non-renewable sources of energy (Henley, ernest, and Stephen 23)....
1 Pages (250 words) Assignment

What is the foundationalist response to the Pyrhhonian sceptical challenge

hellip; The fundamental principle of the Pyrrhonian skepticism is that in matters of opinion, observing quietude is noble, while in matters concerning things that are unavoidable, adapting moderate feelings is the most appropriate approach.... The essence behind this principle of Pyrrhonian skepticism is that; a person, who spends his entire life giving opinions regarding anything that is in nature as either good or bad, spends his entire life in a disquiet state The general argument is that knowledge needs justification (Striker, 72)....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

The Possibility of Someone Knowing Something Merely Based on Luck

The paper "The Possibility of Someone Knowing Something Merely Based on Luck" gives detailed information about three types of knowledge which are propositional knowledge.... The fundamental argument that has been developed is that knowledge requires something more than a lucky guess.... hellip; The epistemic luck was however used to explain that people who only make guesses may indeed know something as far as the end....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Feminist Epistemology, Contextualism, and Philosophical Skepticism

This essay "Feminist Epistemology, contextualism, and Philosophical Skepticism" presents philosophical skeptics who can refute the claim that human beings believe that they have two legs or two arms on the basis of their predisposition that all human beliefs cannot be justified.... hellip; Brister explains that an argument of what an individual believes can be approached from two skepticism concepts.... In of the concepts referred to as philosophical skepticism, most philosophical skeptics tend to have the conception that all beliefs are almost equal to each other and therefore no particular belief may be deemed better than the other....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us